Thursday, November 19, 2026

Is that shampoo, conditioner, or shower gel?

I recently stayed overnight at a hotel during a quick business trip to Cincinnati.  It's always nice that I stay at hotels that supply their own shampoo, conditioner, and shower gel, which means that I don't have to pack my own.  However, if I were to be completely honest, it drives me crazy how most hotels place the bottles of shampoo, conditioner, and shower gel on a rack in the shower.  Here's my most recent example:

















Notice the top line, which is the easiest to read, is the brand name (I think).  Whether the bottle is shampoo or conditioner or shower gel is on the line below in much smaller and barely legible print.  I am like most people in that those of us who need corrective eyewear (either contacts or glasses) do not actually wear them while taking a shower.  In other words, I can't read the smaller print while I am in the shower, so I have no clue whether the bottle is dispensing shampoo, conditioner, or shower gel!  Shower time becomes a grand experiment, and I often wash my wear with shower gel or worse, conditioner!

How can hotels address this problem (assuming that hotels think this is a problem in the first place)?  I see two broad potential solutions involving standardization and the use of forcing functions.  

Standardization would be an easy fix (maybe?).  Every hotel should place each bottle in the same order in every room and in every hotel location.  Of course, the hotel would have to inform their guests about the correct order (and in turn, the guests would have to stay at the same hotel chain on every trip).  

Recall that a "forcing function" is a any mechanism in a process that prevents the human user from making a mistake or error.  Lean Six Sigma calls this a "Poka-yoke" (from the Japanese word for "error-proofing").  Whenever someone withdraws money from an ATM, he or she has to remove their card in order to receive the cash (which prevents the user from leaving his or her card in the machine).  A microwave oven can't be started while the door is open.  There is no way to "plug" a feeding tube into an intravenous line and vice versa.  All of these are great examples of forcing functions.  In the current context, I think it would be difficult (and expensive) to come up with a design that prevents the user from dispensing the shampoo before the conditioner, but hopefully you get the idea.

At the end of the day, the easiest fix of all would be to print the labels "Shampoo", "Conditioner", and "Shower Gel" in very large letters!  All of the other print on the label is a waste of space!  In a way, using large and "easy to read" print is also a form of "Poka-yoke".  It's all about making the right thing the easiest thing to do!  

Can you think of any problems in the health care setting today that could find a solution in either standardization or a Poka-yoke?  I sure can.  And standardization and Poka-yoke has worked!

No comments:

Post a Comment